Notes
Store
info@divacorp.net
INTERVIEW WITH PAUL McCARTHY
November 17, 2026
Days before the opening of his Chocolate Factory at the Performance Art Museum’s new space in Chinatown, we visited Paul McCarthy at his studio, and then talked to him over the phone about the legacy & future of performance art, shock as affect, and what needs to change about the art world.
* * *
[START OF CONVERSATION]
Diva Corp: Hey Paul, what's going on right now? Are you at your studio?
Paul McCarthy: I'm trying to find a place to sit.
Diva: Oh, amazing.
McCarthy: Okay. So I got a place to sit now.
Diva: That’s great.
McCarthy: Yeah, so, I'm installing the chocolate shop right now, at the museum. Chocolate Factory. It should be almost all done. Well not all done, but at least to the point that it starts making chocolate.
Diva: Will it start making chocolate this week?
McCarthy: Yeah. Yeah, it started.
Diva: And this is the third time you’ve staged this installation, right?
McCarthy: Yeah.
Diva: Was it always a part of the vision for it to be iterative like this?
McCarthy: I mean, originally, I just wanted to fill a gallery with these chocolate figurines, right? And I sort of did it in New York – to some degree, I did it. And then in France, I completely filled the Mint [the Monnaie de Paris]… the upstairs of the Mint.
But it sort of changed over time. Always, there was this idea of making a chocolate factory.
There were two ideas. One was that I would make a chocolate factory in the middle of a gallery and produce chocolate figurines ‘til I filled the whole place. All the bathrooms, the desks, the offices. Everything, you know. I would just produce. And it was just this idea of excess… of artists and objects and sculptures and paintings… something about that, I guess.
And then, you know, a piece sort of progresses. First, I was thinking about an abstract sculpture. Then at one point, it was a butt plug – I’d made this piece years ago of a butt plug on a chair and called it a Brancusi on a pedestal, or an Arp on a pedestal. I’d also done a piece with Jason Rhoades about a butt plug. And then the Santa Claus with the butt plug came up. So I did it. Though it still took quite a while to get the figurine to a point that we could manufacture it in chocolate.
And then we did it in New York, at Maccarone. And there, we made the figurine, we packaged it, and we sold it in the shop.
Diva: What was the second idea? You said there were two parts to the original…
McCarthy: Oh, the other part was that the installation could be sold as an edition. Like if somebody bought it they’d be buying a franchise. I thought about it like a McDonald's franchise. It would be a factory that you could actually buy, and you’d get the molds and all that, and you could manufacture chocolate. It was kind of a joke. Nobody bought it, but, of course, I don't know whether I thought they would.
Diva: And the Paris installation was different from New York.
McCarthy: Yeah. When it went to the Mint, we couldn't make a food-grade chocolate factory because of all the regulations. The Mint is a very classical building. It’s right on the river; it hadn't been opened in fifty years or something. It’s a different type of space, so the original idea of filling a gallery evolved and it became a second thing, more of an installation that just made chocolate figurines to fill the space.
And there I put it in a set. Somebody had given me this old set, like a film set, and it had “Brothel” written on it. I don't know what film it was used for, television, whatever it was… It was just kind of, you know, a second-rate set.
Diva: What about that object at your studio? The thing that looks like a mine from the ocean…
McCarthy: That was one of the original things I was interested in, this thing called a spinner. It’s this object that rotates and spins and coats chocolate on the mold. It’s kind of the center of the factory, the machinery of all of it.
Diva: Got it.
McCarthy: Anyway, when I did the Mint, I enclosed all of it, so the people spent, you know, six, seven weeks in there making chocolate figurines and their sculptures. So, the whole thing’s also a type of performance, because you had these people making the figurines and other people watching them. And in the Mint they wore these red chocolatier jackets and all had blonde wigs, so they were sort of characters.
And they made something like five to ten thousand chocolate figurines. And I saved a lot from New York. I don't know, maybe three thousand chocolate figurines, all boxed up, packed with shredded Artforums. But in the Mint they were a different box.
Then all of it sat in storage, including all the chocolate that I had. At one point, I threw away some of it. I don't know how much I kept – like fifty of these five foot by four foot towers of boxed chocolates.
And then fast forward, the museum, they asked, I think I was talking to Samuel [Vasquez, PAM director], and he said something about a fundraiser. And I said, “I got a chocolate factory.” It was kind of a joke, I didn't think they would do it. And then he asked to do it.
So this one is different than the Mint, and it's different than New York. I mean, the building is, you know… the part of town, there's a burnt building next to it. And there's a lot of action on the street. It isn't like the Mint. And it's not like a New York gallery, like a fancy gallery, so it’s a different setting.
So, yeah, I was keeping all the material. And I didn't know what I would ever do with it. But now it's here.
Does it happen again? Yeah, probably at some point.
Diva: And some of that material will be in this new iteration?
McCarthy: For this show, I’ll put in maybe half of what I have of the stacks from New York. So, these towers are in here. And now they're starting to make chocolate today. So it'll start to fill up over the next month.
Diva: Did you have to modify the space? In New York, you had to reoutfit the gallery space with new AC and ventilation and plumbing to make it a true factory, right? To be up to code.
McCarthy: No. With a kind of building like this, it's almost impossible, right? To make it food-grade, it's not just air conditioning. You’d have to completely sanitize the place. That's pretty hard to do. The Mint couldn't do it either. So it's sort of two parts. The food grade comes out of another place.
Diva: Any other differences?
McCarthy: Well, I redesigned the package… pretty quickly… but I kind of like it. Or I do like it… I guess I like it. [Laughs.] We'll see if I like it in a couple of months.
Diva: Only time will tell.
McCarthy: Yeah, I think so.
Diva: And the show will be inaugurating the space. Like a soft launch.
McCarthy: Well, this space is where they’re at right now. I don't know what happens in the future. But, yeah, it's the first show. I mean, they've done other things for a couple of years. They've done events. But it's their first time with a space.
Diva: You're on the board of trustees for the museum, too. What’s the importance of this kind of museum today, to you? And why a physical space now?
McCarthy: Ah… why? I mean, as far as you want to go back – back to futurism or Dada… or really however you want to classify performance – I think there's something about what performance art is and what it was certainly in the 60s and 70s, if not 50s… Like with Fluxus… It was an alternative art world. A lot of those artists were against selling and the view of art as commodity and all that. And performance, you know, by its nature… what can you own? Of course, it kind of got marketed in the 70s all the way up through the 90s, whether it was Naumann or Acconci or whatever, sold as photographs and videotapes.
But I think at this point, the art world is so… you know: it's art fairs. Where, yeah, I guess you could have a performance at an art fair, but the art fair is sort of like… it's for paintings. So, in today’s art world, the artist hardly has a voice in how their work is put up or where it’s staged. It's all been taken over by the galleries and the salespeople.
And I think, in a way, performance has always been an alternative form. It's where a voice can be.
Diva: So, the museum is for that voice.
McCarthy: I mean, yeah. You know, it’s about the history or understanding of what performance has been. And then there's the question: What is it now? And it seems like that’s a good thing for it to try and determine, to grapple with what a performance museum might be, or just what a performance location might be, or a performance grouping… Support…
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: I think it's a bit of a question for them, and I think there’s a reason for it right now. I think it's some kind of voice on the other side of the commercialism of the art world, right?
Diva: How were things different when you were starting out? Performance, the art world…
McCarthy: Well, in the early ‘70s, the most famous artists in the world were Vito Acconci and Joseph Beuys. That's a different kind of artist. Or Carolee Schneeman or something, Judson Church and all that. That's not the case now. Performance had a different place in the art world, you know, the magazines at the time…
So, how do you go back? Where does it go now? I'm not sure. With the digital world and the internet and social media… And then you’ve got artists reacting in an opposite direction, like reacting against technology…
Anyway, it was something that was accepted, it was part of the dialogue. And the art world has pushed that away.
But then, I think the “art world” now has separated itself anyway, like there's a separation. I mean, there are a lot of interesting younger artists that are just not going to get picked up by the art world, unless the art world changes. The art world has to change. The commercial art world. Which all comes down to collectors, them understanding it. I think that was part of the difference. There were collectors that were behind Lawrence Weiner, you know.
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: I don't know whether that exists now. I mean, in my case, I'm kind of part of the art world and I'm not part of the art world, so…
Diva: Part of you feels separate from the art world? Or, like, at odds?
McCarthy: I mean, I don't know… I kind of operate in two different worlds. Within the art world itself, the gallery art world, yeah, but there's certain bodies of my work that are just never seen. They’re just not going to show up. But I kind of wedge it in there, too, at the same time.
Diva: What do you mean?
McCarthy: Well, like if I do a show now, I often screen the films in a theatre somewhere or something. Sometimes galleries will show videos, but they don't really… How interested are they in them, right? I mean, who's going to buy them?... Who buys videos, you know?
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: And for me, I mean, a large part of what I do is make videos, you know, but there's a lot of it that's just never seen.
Diva: And so you'll show them at the Aero, like you did a couple of years ago. That’s the stuff you're talking about?
McCarthy: Yeah. Like that.
Diva: Do you think that has anything to do with the social climate? As in, do you think they’re not showing it because it’s shocking or something? Or too risky? A lot of the artists, the performance artists, you mentioned, they were playing with the edge. And doing it in galleries… Maybe it’s just too hot of a social climate to be doing that.
McCarthy: Yeah, I mean, obviously it has some reason that it's not being seen.
Diva: Which is interesting, too, because I think a lot of people will say, like, “you can't be transgressive now,” like the audience isn’t going to see anything more shocking than what we see on the internet, or what we see every day on the street. I mean, is there still space today for that?
McCarthy: Well, I mean, I've never really thought whether I was trying to make work that was shocking.
Diva: Right.
McCarthy: Maybe there is something in that, though. Like there's some kind of reaction, or there's something about it that’s shocking, and I get something out of it. But I don't think that's really what goes on. Like a lot of other stuff goes on. I'm dealing with issues that I want to deal with. So, I'm not looking to, I don't think I'm looking to really shock people.
Diva: Right.
McCarthy: I remember, years ago, I was showing a video at REDCAT, and a friend of mine went out in the lobby – she had already seen the video, she'd been working on it. And there was a guy out there drinking at the bar, and they talk, and he says that he's a painter, he's done these paintings, and da-da-da, and then he says, “That stuff in there” – my video, you know – “we all know about that now.”
And I thought, “Well, do you really?” That was one thought: Do you really? And then my other thought was: I don't care what you know.
For me, I wanted to make that. This is what I do. So, I’m not sure it's a valid critique anyway. Like, is it just shock that the work is about? I think the work is not just about shock. It's, like, maybe you don't know how to read it, you know.
Diva: Yeah. I wonder if there's an over-coding, like people are just sort of coding the work as shock rather than being able to access anything beyond that.
McCarthy: Yeah. Or they dismiss a video work by saying, “Well, video… everybody makes video now, they’ve got iPhones.” So maybe it's kind of at that point. Like, if you just think about it as shocking, that we don't need to shock because there’s already so much on the internet that's transgressive, or shocking, or whatever…
If that’s the case, I think: Well, how many paintings can you paint? When does that wear out? You know, like, when we have painted so much, don't we already know that then?
So, it gets into this comparing thing. There was something really interesting about the 90s, because almost anything was okay, whether it was a painting or a video or a sculpture or a performance. Or whether you changed genres… became a filmmaker. It all seemed to have a… there was a dialogue around things, the discussion was interesting. And I think the art world changed to the point that it… it just pushed a lot of things out. Pushed a lot of voices that are needed, in some way, now. Maybe not even voices, just feelings, or expressions about feelings.
Diva: You’ve been pretty involved over the years in the community, getting behind some of those voices, those expressions you’re talking about. I mean in addition to helping with PAM. You taught at UCLA; contributed to your daughter Mara’s space, The Box; in the ‘70s, you had the radio show with John Duncan, Close Radio, that featured a lot of young sound artists. Can you talk about that? How does that type of thing fit into your practice?
McCarthy: Well, in the 70s I did, you know, magazines and that radio program and a performance festival. And that was more about the artists among themselves, about artists supporting and being involved with each other's art. And I think that still goes on, you know. And then we did the gallery for 18 years. And then at one point we couldn't do it anymore. Just couldn't.
So what happens now? I guess Mara, [my wife] Karen, and I are trying to figure out what happens next.
I mean, I had this idea after the performance festival and the radio program in the ‘70s, I thought about becoming an art agent, right? It was a joke. It was a joke – like a movie star agent – but at the same time, kind of serious. That kind of thing exists now, you know? And I don't think that I’m going to form some kind of agency, and I don't think Mara is either, but I think there's something about just trying to be— … Maybe there’s some way to help. And there’s so many different types of venues, like places to show… so, I don't know if it's “support” or not, but I kind of, that's what I do, you know. I kind of show all over the place.
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: I mean the Chocolate Factory is kind of like that, right? You know, there's money that hopefully goes to the museum, so…
Diva: A lot of these projects are collaborations, in a way, too.
McCarthy: Yeah.
Diva: Can you talk about that? Like your collaborative work? How do you know when someone’s right to collaborate with. You worked a lot with Mike Kelley, and Jason Rhoades. Recently you’ve worked with Lilith Stangenberg. How do those relationships begin?
McCarthy: I mean, I collaborated a lot with my son, too, Damon. Not as much now, but I did for quite a while.
I think these collaborations, I mean… How did they start, you know?
With Mike and I, we knew each other. He was 10 years younger, kind of part of the CalArts thing. And we just talked over time and always kind of said that maybe we'd get together sometime and do something. And then I got a grant to make a videotape. And I asked him if he wanted to be in it.
And so we made these two tapes. Well, actually one: Family Tyranny. And I think we liked working with each other.
After that, our work often started with jokes. We’d be on the telephone talking about something, and there’d be a joke, and then we’d spend the next two years trying to make something. I think it was a little like that with Jason, too.
With Damon, it was always, you know: he would have an idea. Like he said, why don't we remake Pirates of the Caribbean, the ride? It was all in relationship to Bush and Iraq, though, which happened at that time. Because the ride at Disneyland was really about an invasion. The pirates invade a village and drown the men and put the women on, you know, auction. And so it was like a kind of metaphor for what was happening.
And with Lilith, it was pretty much… We were shooting a video. I didn't know her very well, but I was shooting a video and I said something like, “It looks like The Night Porter,” because she was in a tile room, like that scene in The Night Porter where he's shooting a gun at her. That wasn't happening, but it was just this room we were in. And she said, like, “That’s my favorite film,” and then somebody said we should remake it. And it took two years. And I still haven't really edited it.
So, I think these things sort of grow out of… they grow out of something like a comment or a joke or, you know. I don’t know.
All of them lasted a long time. Mike and I did a lot, same with Jason. I think Lilith and I have done a hundred performances. So, I mean, that's still going on.
Diva: Have you made all of those into films? You showed a couple at the Aero…
McCarthy: Night Porter we're still editing. How long is it? Night Porter’s probably when it's done, maybe seven hours long.
Diva: Wow.
Paul: And A&E is probably somewhere around ten or twelve two-hour films, like a series. We've edited four, I think. And the drawing sessions, there's probably fifty of them, and we've edited five or something. There's tons of terabytes of video. Same with the Stagecoach stuff. We lost a lot of stuff in the [Altadena] fire. A lot of video.
Diva: Like hard drives and stuff?
McCarthy: Yeah, we lost, I don't know, three years of work, I guess. Damon was editing. His edit studio burned down.
Diva: I read that. That must’ve been awful.
McCarthy: Yeah.
Diva: So, do you reshoot those? Or are you just sort of starting fresh…
McCarthy: No, we have the raw.
Diva: Oh good.
McCarthy: Yeah, but still it’s just like… God, going back and starting over is crazy.
Diva: Yeah, that's hard.
McCarthy: That's really hard. But anyway, that's all the Western stuff.
Diva: Didn’t you show a part of that in Vienna?
McCarthy: Well, Lilith and I did Night Porter on stage for four nights in Vienna. But, yeah, I showed CSSFC, the stagecoach movie in Vienna. I don’t know when that was. 2000 and something.
Diva: How did you learn how to collaborate like this? I mean it seems consistent across time, and successful. Was there a mentor, or…
McCarthy: Well, I never… I mean, during the ‘60s and ‘70s, we were part of – myself and Karen – we were part of these sort of collective art groups. They would all be around our age, or two or three years younger or older.
So, I did a lot of collaborative art in San Francisco, and Utah too, but then when we moved to L.A. in 1970, I, at that point, had kind of stopped. When we moved here, it became more individual. I kind of wanted a break from all that. But I was close to Kaprow, you know. And Burden was my age and all that.
But the first kind of collaboration that I really did – I might be wrong – I think the first one was probably with Mike in ‘87.
I mean, I did the collaborative stuff with Duncan, the radio show and that kind of stuff. And with Barbara Smith and Nancy Buchanan. That was all in the ‘70s, but that was more like… John and I never made a piece together. We worked on each other's pieces, but never worked on one together. And then we worked on showing other artists or stuff like that.
So, yeah, I think one of the first collaborations I did was with Mike. After that long break, probably it was close to 15 years before I did a collaboration with another artist, I guess. And it was Mike.
And then Mike and I did… I don't know how many we did together, five, six, or something. So Mike and then Jason happened, and then Damon and then Lilith. So…
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: But they were long collaborations, you know. Like we kind of would, you know, every year or so, or two years, we'd start on another one. And it would all just happen, they weren't planned.
Diva: Can you talk more about John Duncan? I’ve always been curious about his Scare piece. You were involved with that.
McCarthy: Oh, the shooting?
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: The gun one? He did it to a couple of people. He just went to a house with a blank gun and a stocking over his head. He knocked on the door. So I went and opened it. And there was a guy with a gun pointed at me and a stocking over his head. And he fired the gun. And I shut the door. [Laughs] And it was kind of like, “What the hell?” Like, you know, I'm not shot. And then I opened the door and he was running down the street… And I kind of thought, “That could be John.”
Diva: And afterward, did he, like, call you up say, “That was me”?
McCarthy: No, I don't even remember how it came out.
Diva: Interesting.
McCarthy: I mean, I sort of… I understood it. I know what he was going for. In a way, you know, I wasn't too upset.
It was fucked up, though. I mean, for a second, it was really fucked up.
Diva: Yeah. What is that piece about for you?
McCarthy: Well, I mean, he's giving you a sensation. Right?
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: He's producing a sensation. Is it scary? Yeah, for a second. And then there's this crazy moment where the gun goes off! [Laughs.] And then, of course, there's nothing. So it's kind of a, yeah, it's a kind of shock. You hardly have time to think about it. I think I was immediately – I didn't, you know… the gun went off so fast. Like the door opens up, I register the gun… Register… kind of register. Then the gun goes off, right? And I shut the door. And then it's kind of like another thing, right? Like, well, that was a gag, you know. That was a fucked-up gag in a way, you could say. But I think he was… it's the kind of work John was making at that time.
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: A lot of it was about himself. Putting himself in situations, you know.
Diva: Yeah.
McCarthy: And there were effects, you know. Like if you help John do something, then you were in it, right? You're part of it somehow, or you're going to watch something happen.
Diva: Yeah, I think one thing for me that I love about his work, too, is that it lives on almost more through, yeah, like rumor or hearsay – these stories you’re telling – rather than through any physical document, any video documentation or anything like that.
McCarthy: Yeah.
Diva: And he seems to be aware, obviously, of that.
McCarthy: I think so.
Diva: Do you know what he’s up to now?
McCarthy: Well, he became more and more involved in sound and music. He moved to Japan and Amsterdam and then... I’d sort of lose contact with him for three or four years at a time. I mean, I haven't talked to him in quite a few years. The last time I knew he was in Florence or something. So he moved around. And still does sound work, you know. I was in a couple of groups with him.
Diva: Music groups.
McCarthy: Yeah, yeah.
Diva: So he’s still working. And you’re definitely still going. When I was at your studio the other week, you showed a lot of stuff that was – a lot of it was in progress but there was a lot that you’d shown years ago, that you seemed to be thinking about. What are you interested in right now? Where’s your engine these days?
McCarthy: Well, a lot of the stuff in the studio was made… what? It’s ten to twenty years old, that stuff, right? There are a few new sculptures, but not many. Like those mechanical pieces are twenty years old. And I'm working on them. There's a lot in the studio dealing with existing work made from another period of time. And I don't know whether we even looked at what's going on now, what’s been going on for the last ten or fifteen years, twenty years practically. It's a lot with videos and photographs and performance and drawings.
So, the studio is kind of housing stuff right now. I mean, I don't know what I’d do with it, right? Like what do I do with it? I don't know what I… At this point, do I need a big studio? Probably my work doesn't need it. It's like storage. But, I mean, there's a lot of writing and a lot of photographs. I mean millions… a lot of AI, a lot of virtual reality, a lot of that, and a lot of video. Terabytes. Upstairs is where all that is.
And downstairs, I have plans for some of that work. That's what's in this chocolate factory. I'm showing about a quarter of all the chocolates saved from 2007. And then it's the set. And then it's, I made some new pieces, a Santa Claus and a stack of tables are made from existing work, existing stuff.
So I'm kind of working on past work. And, and then when I did, I did this whole thing of Santa Claus and the Elf – Eva, S.S. – it was Saint Santa and Eva Elf, I shot it in the house from White Snow. So I'm recycling things. But a lot of that bottom floor is just storage. And those big sets. A lot of that work is from the sixties to sometime in early 2000, I guess. And mid-2000.
And since then, it's been a lot about, yeah, other mediums like video and drawing. And I'm really interested in both of those. They're more immediate in a way. Video's immediate, but then the editing takes forever. Especially how we've shot the videos. They're all shot with four or five cameras. They’re not shot like normal films at all. They're all improvisations that go on for twenty minutes to two or three hours.
Diva: How did it feel to work in that White Snow set? To revisit it, or recycle it like you’re saying.
McCarthy: I mean, the whole thing of it being the house I grew up in is interesting. That was always crazy. I made that when Mike was working on his house, the one he grew up in. We both did it about the same time. And both houses had an underworld, an area underneath them.
But there’s nothing spooky about it for me. There's none of that. I think it's interesting. I mean, the White Snow piece… my parents were kind of the age of Walt Disney and, you know, to a degree, Snow White. So that’s tied up in the video. And there's conversations in there that are conversations I imagined my parents having. And the way they would drink coffee. There is like some reenactment, some kind of references back to my parents and also the, you know, grownups and grownups drinking and stuff like that when I made White Snow… Things from when you're young.
But for the most part, it's not connected to the family as much. It's in there, but along with that is, you know, Fassbinder and Karel and the Disney Brothers. There's all kinds of things inside of it. And Duchamp. There’s references all through that are as strong or stronger than the family ones.
My parents were very, I don't know… They were ‘50s, but liberal. And I had no arguments with my parents. I didn't. I left when I was young, but I didn't have issues. So, there was something where it's what I imagined my parents would be okay with. It's always been more of a question as to how my brothers and sisters would react to it.
So then by going back and making drawings as Santa Claus and the Elf in it, I thought, it seemed like that was interesting. Exactly what it's about, I'm not sure… People could read it all kinds of ways, I guess, or in certain ways. But it seemed interesting that these two bodies of work are sort of encased in this set of a house I grew up in.
And also my family was totally into Christmas. Santa Claus was, like, a big deal. And the first drawing I remember doing was Santa Claus. So, it’s in the past, and it's interesting for me that I made these drawings in that space.
Diva: The first drawing you ever did was Santa Claus?
Paul: Yeah.
Diva: Wow.
Paul: And after I made the drawings with Lilith as Santa Claus, I kept the beard. So it’s been probably almost a year and a half. Might almost be two years that I've had a beard. I just didn't cut off the beard. Which is very strange to me: Why you didn't cut off the beard? It's kind of like you became that character, but kind of not. Like, it's something else, I think.
I had ideas of going back and making more videos about Santa Claus, but I haven't done it yet. Maybe it's out there.
Diva: Maybe it's coming.
Paul: Maybe it's coming, I don't know.
Diva: Well, I look forward to seeing that. And the Chocolate Factory very soon.
McCarthy: Yeah, next week.
Diva: Thank you so much for taking the time. It means a lot. Very generous.
McCarthy: Okay. Adios.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
- - - - -